Borderlands 2 Won't Get Fooled Again Mission Tips And Completion Details

The quest titled Won't Get Fooled Again in Borderlands 2 is a short detective side mission given by Marshall Friedman in Sanctuary. Players are tasked with investigating the murder of Justin MacReady by identifying the culprit among four identical brothers. Rather than relying on heavy firefights, completing this objective requires careful deduction and attentiveness to NPC dialogue.
Gathering Clues From Sanctuary Residents
To identify the true killer, players must speak with key witnesses around Sanctuary to collect critical evidence. Marshall Friedman mentions that the victim was taken down with a single precise shot. Moxxi reveals that she shot the suspect as he fled, noting that his shield absorbed her initial attacks.
Dr. Zed provides the final piece of information by confirming he patched up the injured brother shortly after the incident. Combining these accounts tells you that the perpetrator carries a sniper rifle, active shield protection, and possesses full health. Inspecting each brother's status bar closely allows players to pinpoint the exact suspect without relying on guessing.
Identifying the Real Culprit
While players can review options, provides valuable insights into game mechanics and quest progression. Examining the Gutter brothers reveals that only Barlo Gutter satisfies every clue given by the witnesses. He is equipped with a sniper rifle, holds an active shield, and shows a completely full health bar.
Accusing Barlo immediately causes him to confess to the crime before justice is served. If an incorrect brother is chosen, the true killer attempts to run away, though players still receive mission rewards regardless. Accurately solving the mystery grants players experience points and the Law pistol reward.
Tips for Fast Completion
For players who want to complete the side mission quickly, interviewing the witnesses is entirely optional. You can directly approach Barlo Gutter as soon as the quest starts and make your accusation. This allows vault hunters to claim their rewards without extra backtracking across Sanctuary.
This mission serves as a unique change of pace from traditional combat objectives in Pandora. Understanding the logical deduction behind the clues ensures a smooth turnaround time. It remains one of the most memorable non-combat side quests available during the main campaign.